Presidential Seal TheUSAPresidents.com Presidential Seal

Star GIFWe have pages on every election!Star GIF

Election of 1788-1789

Election of 1792

Election of 1796

Election of 1800

Election of 1804

Election of 1808

Election of 1812

Election of 1816

Election of 1820

Election of 1824

Election of 1828

Election of 1832

Election of 1836

Election of 1840

Election of 1844

Election of 1848

Election of 1852

Election of 1856

Election of 1860

Election of 1864

Election of 1868

Election of 1872

Election of 1876

Election of 1880

Election of 1884

Election of 1888

Election of 1892

Election of 1896

Election of 1900

Election of 1904

Election of 1908

Election of 1912

Election of 1916

Election of 1920

Election of 1924

Twenty-third American presidential election of 1876

1876 election map

AndyHogan14, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Date

The 1876 election took place on Tuesday, November 7, 1876.

Candidates

Final tickets

An image showing Rutherford Hayes for president and William Wheeler for vice president

An image showing Samuel Tilden for president and Thomas Hendricks for vice president

Campaining & major issues

The Grant Administration's scandals got even worse by the time 1876 rolled around. Grant was thinking about going for a third term; he ultimately, though, went against it. Rutherford Hayes, the Republican candidate, was popular for being another Civil War hero and was even wounded in combat, making him a perfect successor to Grant. However, because Samuel Tilden was a strong Democrat and because of the Grant Administration's various scandals, the Democrats posed a true threat to the Republicans. For reasons mentioned later in this page, this would be the last election of the Reconstrucction era of the United States.

Electoral college & turn-out

The electoral college increased to 369 electors; 185 needed to win. 8,418,659 people voted in this election. This would be the second out of five elections in which the winner did not win the popular vote.

Results

Additional info & summary

Originally, it looked like Tilden would win. He led the popular vote and electoral vote; Republicans disputed it however. Florida, Louisiana, Oregon and South Carolina (20 electoral votes) were disputed. There had been chaos in the states; in one of them, 150 black Republicans were killed. A Constitutional crisis began as hatred and dispute swept the country. Angry people surrounded Rutherford Hayes' home, but Hayes said it was too soon for the results to be finalized. President Grant, though quietly, armed Washington D.C. with extra protection as the crisis unfolded. The Democratic House and Republican Senate on January 15, 1877, decided to create an electoral commission of fifteen people: five Representatives, five Senators, and five Supreme Court Justices. The majority party in each chamber chose three people, while the minority chose two. Because of this, there happened to be five Republicans and five Democrats. Of the Supreme Court there were two Republicans and two Democrats. The fifth justice was a man named David Davis who was an Independent. However, Democrats tried to win him over by electing him to the Senate. However, it severely backfired. Davis excused himself from the commission, and since the rest of the Justices were Republicans, Republican Joseph Bradley took his spot. His vote broke the tie, and with the commission adjourning on March 2, it announced that it had awarded all disputed votes to Hayes with a final vote of 8-7. Hayes was inaugurated privately, with a public inauguration "without disturbance", taking place on March 5. However, Democrats likely agreed to it because of an unofficial compromise referred to as the Compromise of 1877, which officially ended Reconstruction by withdrawing the last federal soldiers from South Carolina and Louisiana. This election is one of the most studied elections in American history; It is still brought up in today's politics, most recently when Senator Ted Cruz in 2021 during the 2020 election certification suggested an electoral commission just like 1876 be created to decide the election, though the motion failed.

Other attributions (listed from top to bottom)

Currier & Ives., Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

No attribution available, from Wikimedia Commons


TheUSAPresidents.com

About UsLegalPolitical policyReliability

Information on this site should not be plagiarized. This site is intended for hobby purposes, not commercial. Visit here for more information.